I have just started doing an IB project with my 8th grade class. I thought that the discussion questions were worth sharing. The discussion that came from the students was extremely insightful and showed a wonderful amount of global awareness.
Who Has the Power??
Over the course of the year we have discussed many topics, many of which have the theme of Power. In class we have discussed community, and what it means to be a part of a community. We have discussed how people come to power, and who plays a role in this. We have discussed what happened in our country’s history that set up our countries fundamental principles to determine power. Lastly, we have studied how our country separates power.
“Who has the Power in the United States?” Who do you think has the power? Why? Is it the people? What kind of people? Business? What type? Government? Which part?
Look at Egypt: What will Egypt’s government look like? Where will the power lie? How are you going to visually represent it? My old picture of Egypt was a pyramid. Both symbolic because the leader is at the top and the people at the bottom, but also because it stands for Egypt’s history (and so much of it is build literally on the backs of the poorest members). After listening to many news programs and interviews with the people in Egypt, what do you think they hold most important? Who will have the Power?
I think that it is important to note that students really did not get involved in the conversation until I told them that there was no "Right" or "Wrong." Its so interesting to me that students look for the right, don't want to be wrong, and don't know what to do when there is no right or wrong....